Dating InsightsNovember 16, 2026·7 min read

Should You Get Back With Your Ex? How to Decide

How to decide whether to get back with an ex: the questions that matter, signs it could work, signs it won't and how to handle the holiday-season text.

Quick Answer

Get back with an ex only if you can name why it ended and what has concretely changed since. Breakups caused by circumstances, like a move, a career crisis or bad timing, can be worth revisiting when those circumstances have changed. Breakups caused by how you treated each other or by wanting different things rarely resolve on their own. If the pull is mostly loneliness, nostalgia or fear of starting over, especially during the holidays, it's a signal to wait, not to reunite.

Late November is when exes start reappearing. A "happy Thanksgiving" text, a like on an old photo, a run-in at a mutual friend's party. The holidays bring up nostalgia, time off and a feeling that everyone else is paired up.

Sometimes getting back together is the right call. Often it isn't. Here's how to tell the difference without relying on how you feel at 11 p.m. on a Tuesday in December.

Should You Get Back With Your Ex?

The question that decides almost everything is: why did it end, and what is different now?

Breakups usually fall into one of three types.

Circumstantial breakups. One of you moved, took a demanding job, went through a family crisis or simply wasn't ready. The relationship itself worked; life got in the way. These are the strongest candidates for a second try, if the circumstance has genuinely changed.

Behavioral breakups. Something about how you treated each other: poor communication, unresolved conflict, jealousy, neglect, dishonesty. These can be fixed, but only if someone has actually done the work to change, not just felt bad about it.

Fundamental breakups. You wanted different things: kids or no kids, marriage or not, New York or somewhere else, very different ideas about money or religion. These rarely resolve with time, because neither person was wrong. You just didn't want the same life.

If you can't place your breakup in one of these categories, that's the first thing to figure out. Write down, in one or two plain sentences, why it ended. If you and your ex would write different sentences, that matters too.

Signs Getting Back Together Could Work

None of these guarantee anything, but they're the conditions under which second chances tend to succeed.

The reason for the breakup is gone. The long-distance stretch ended. The job that consumed them is behind them. The thing that made it impossible no longer exists.

Someone has changed something specific. Not "I've grown a lot," but "I started therapy and I've been working on shutting down during conflict, here's what I do differently now." Specific changes are visible in behavior, not just described.

You both want it, independently. Not one person persuading the other, and not a mutual slide back into the relationship after a few drinks.

You've had real time apart. Enough to know you've been fine on your own and are choosing this, not running back to avoid being alone.

You still respect each other. If the breakup was handled with care and you can talk about it honestly, that's a good foundation. Contempt doesn't fade with time.

Signs You Shouldn't Get Back With Your Ex

You're mostly lonely. Missing companionship is real, but it's not the same as missing this person. Ask yourself whether you'd want them back if you'd just met someone else you liked.

You're remembering a highlight reel. Nostalgia edits out the hard parts. If your memories are all of the first six months, try to remember a typical Tuesday in the last six.

Nothing has changed except time. Time alone rarely fixes behavioral or fundamental problems. If neither of you can say what's different, the relationship will likely end the same way, just later.

It was a cycle. If you've already broken up and gotten back together more than once, the pattern is information. Each round tends to make the next breakup easier to predict and harder to leave.

You're afraid of starting over. Dating again can feel daunting, especially after years with one person. That's a reason to be patient with yourself, not a reason to go back. Our post on how long to wait after a breakup to date covers how to know when you're ready.

There was disrespect, control or dishonesty. These aren't compatibility issues. They're about how someone treats a partner, and they're the hardest to change.

Why Exes Reach Out During the Holidays

A text from an ex in late November or December usually says more about the season than about the relationship.

The holidays stack up every trigger for reaching out: nostalgia, family asking whether you're seeing anyone, couples everywhere, time off with too much space to think and a drink or two at a party. Someone who would never have texted in March may well text in December.

That doesn't make the message insincere. But it does mean it's not evidence that they've changed. Before replying, ask:

  • Is this a reflection of how they feel, or of what they've done? Missing you isn't the same as having addressed why it ended.
  • What do they actually want? A conversation, a hookup, a relationship, reassurance? Vague messages often reflect vague intentions.
  • How will you feel in January? Decisions made in the holiday glow get tested in the cold, dark weeks after.

If you're curious, it's fine to respond warmly and suggest a real conversation after the holidays. That gives both of you time to see whether the interest survives the season.

How to Talk About Getting Back Together

If you both want to try, have the hard conversation before you're back in the relationship, not after.

Name the reason it ended, specifically. "We fought a lot" is too vague. "When we disagreed, I'd go quiet for days and you'd feel shut out" is something you can work with.

Say what each of you has done differently since. If the answer is nothing, take that seriously.

Agree on what you'd do if the old problem returns. It probably will, at least once. Couples who succeed the second time usually have a plan for the familiar fight.

Decide on a pace. Moving back in or picking up exactly where you left off erases the chance to see whether things are actually different. Dating again, slowly, gives you better information.

Check whether you're being honest about yourself. It's easy to frame a breakup as mostly the other person's fault. The question "what was my part?" is more useful than "have they changed?"

What If You're Not Sure?

Uncertainty is normal. Often it means one part of you misses the person while another part remembers why it ended.

A few things help:

  • Wait. A decision that's right in December will still be right in February.
  • Talk to a friend who saw the relationship up close, not one who only heard your side of the breakup.
  • Notice what you're comparing. If the alternative feels like loneliness, any familiar relationship will look good. If the alternative is meeting someone new and well-suited, the comparison changes.

That last point is one reason people find curated dating useful after a breakup. Meeting a few well-matched people in short, low-stakes settings, like Tenr's 10-minute video dates, gives you a realistic sense of what else is out there instead of comparing your ex to an empty calendar.

If you're thinking about an ex while dating someone new, our post on talking about your ex when dating covers how much to share. If you suspect you're being used to fill the gap after someone else's breakup, see signs you're the rebound. And if you keep returning to the same kind of relationship, why you keep attracting the wrong people is a useful read.

The Bottom Line

Getting back with an ex works best when the breakup was about circumstances that have since changed, or when someone has made specific, visible changes to the behavior that ended it. It works worst when the pull is loneliness, nostalgia or fear of starting over, which is exactly what the holidays tend to amplify. Before you say yes, be able to answer two questions in plain language: why did it end, and what is different now?

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you know if you should get back with your ex?

Start with why it ended. If the reason was circumstantial, like a move or bad timing, and that circumstance has genuinely changed, it can work. If the reason was about how you treated each other or what you each want, ask what specifically is different now. If neither of you can name a concrete change, the relationship will likely end the same way.

Is it a bad idea to get back with an ex?

Not always. It's a bad idea when the motivation is loneliness, fear of starting over or nostalgia for the best moments, rather than a clear-eyed view that the core problem has been solved.

Why do exes reach out around the holidays?

The holidays bring up nostalgia, loneliness and time off to think, so many people reach out to old partners in late November and December. A holiday text says more about how someone is feeling right now than about whether they've changed.

How long should you wait before getting back with an ex?

Long enough to make the decision from a stable place rather than in the immediate grief of the breakup. There's no fixed number, but if you're still in the acute stage of missing them, it's too soon to judge whether the relationship itself should return.

What should you talk about before getting back together?

Talk about why it ended, in specific terms, what each of you has done differently since, and what you would each do if the same problem came back. Agree on what's different this time before you're back in the routine of the relationship.

Found this useful? Share it.
Share

Related reading

Ready to find your person?

Tenr is the invite-only 10-minute date app for high achievers.

linkedin.com/in/
By applying, you agree to receive SMS messages from Tenr for account updates and verification codes, including two-factor authentication. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out, HELP for help. View our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.